Gordon Lee Trial Ends in Mistrial

Mon, November 5th, 2007 at 12:00am PST

Comic Books
CBR News Team, Editor

Official Press Release

The case against Gordon Lee took another in an ongoing series of bizarre turns this afternoon when statements made by State prosecutor John Tully during opening arguments led to a mistrial.

Lee and his legal team, paid for by the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, appeared in court this morning for jury selection and returned in the afternoon to begin the actual trial. Before the jury was brought in to begin the trial, lead counsel Alan Begner argued an oral motion in limine asking the judge to instruct prosecutors that they could not admit statements from their witnesses alluding to Lee's character and previous legal actions Lee has been party to. Prosecutors assured the court that they had instructed their witnesses not to address Lee's previous conviction for selling adult comics to an adult. Then during opening statements in front of the jury, prosecutor Tully said witnesses will testify that Gordon was defensive and that Gordon had told police, "I've been through this before," a clear reversal of his earlier statement to the judge that prosecutors would not be entering such statements into the record.

When Tully made his statement, defense counsel stared at each other in disbelief before Begner leapt up to demand a mistrial. Judge Larry Salmon put his head in his hands and called a 15 minute recess.

Upon returning to the courtroom, as a result of Tully's statement, Salmon declared a mistrial, because the statements alluding to the prior incident contaminated the jury beyond repair for a fair trial.

"This is a victory, but we wish it was over," said CBLDF lead counsel Alan Begner. "We believe that prosecutors induced this mistrial on purpose, because we had a jury that looked more defense oriented. We're prepared to quickly file a motion to argue that no new trial should be scheduled because this mistrial was intentional and constitutes prosecutorial misconduct."

Begner adds, "Time and again we've been here and have been told to go home because of the prosecutors' actions. Meanwhile, it's Gordon who suffers. It's been three years since this case began, and for three years Gordon has had this hanging over his head. Today his good name is still not cleared."

Lee's trial comes after three years of legal action arising from the Halloween 2004 distribution of Alternative Comics #2, a Free Comic Book Day sampler which featured an excerpt from the critically acclaimed graphic novel The Salon that depicted Pablo Picasso in the nude, and was allegedly handed to a minor. The CBLDF has spent over $80,000 on Lee's defense since taking the case in early 2005, and expects costs to reach six figures by the end of the trial. The case has been ready for trial three times – the first, in April of 2006, when prosecutors dismissed and re-filed the charges because their facts were wrong; the second last August when the judge's illness led to a rescheduling; and today when statements made by the prosecutor led to a mistrial.

"Never in the Fund's history have we seen prosecutorial conduct of this nature," says CBLDF Executive Director Charles Brownstein. "We're dumbfounded by prosecutors assuring the court that they weren't going to do something, and then doing exactly that thing five minutes later. Every step of the way they have been adding further expense to Lee's defense, first by changing their facts, then by entering new indictment after new indictment, and today by contaminating the jury. Nobody, especially a small retailer, can bear this kind of expense on their own. Today's action is clear evidence of why the Fund needs to be around to protect comics."

The next step for the case is uncertain, but could see trial again in 2008.

I'm writing you this letter while the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund's legal

team is in court in Rome, GA defending Gordon Lee. For the last 3 years,

Gordon has been put through a legal wringer by Rome's prosecutors, who are

trying to send him to jail for two years because of a comic book about

Picasso. Thank goodness for the CBLDF, who got Gordon the best lawyers in

the state and picked up the bill – which is likely to reach $100,000 by the

time this is all done.

Win or lose, his case shows why it's important that we support the CBLDF.

Story continues below

For 20 years, the Fund has been going to court to defend retailers and

creators who are singled out by prosecutors because of comics. They arrange

and pay for the best counsel, an expense that would bankrupt most small

retailers and cartoonists. Because of the Fund, we don't need to back down

when faced with bullying prosecutions like the one against Gordon. Because

of the support of people like you and me, the Fund is able to stand up and

fight for comics.

To make sure that they have the resources to pay for Gordon's case and take

on any new threats in 2008, I'm donating a piece of original art I made for

the mini-series Shazam: The Monster Society of Evil. This large image of the

Captain Marvel Family was spread over the backs of all four issues of the

original series and fit together to make a puzzle, and was used again on the

giant sized fold out dust jacket that came with the Deluxe Hard Cover

collection. I rarely part with my original art, but in this case, I know

that it's worth doing. It is my sincere hope that this donation can offset

some of the Fund's expenses as we fight for our right to draw and read what

we want.

Please join me in supporting the Fund by taking this opportunity to make a

tax-deductible donation towards their work. There are lots of ways to do

this - you can sign up for membership, donate a piece of artwork or a rare

comic book from your collection, or buy premiums from their website. And

cash donations are always appreciated.

If you're one of my fellow creators or publishers, you can also donate some

of your time to the Fund by signing for them at conventions and events,

donating signed copies of your work, or something even more creative. If

you're a retailer, why not host a CBLDF fundraiser at your store or sign up

for retail membership?

However you decide to help, now is the time. The Fund is watching out for

comics. We need to stand behind them with our financial support so they can

keep doing their important work. Please support the Fund today.

Sincerely yours,

Jeff Smith


Make A Donation

Your cash donation to the CBLDF goes the furthest towards paying off our

legal bills. Until November 22, all cash donations of $30 or better will

earn you a copy of an all-new signed CBLDF Bone print by Jeff Smith. Prints

will be available on January 1, but you can reserve yours today, and support

the cause at this urgent time. Visit http://cbldf.safeshopper.com/12/cat12

htm?479 to make a donation today.

Free Shipping on Premiums

To build up support for Gordon's trial, for a limited time, the Fund is

offering premiums previously only available at conventions. Signed graphic

novels, comics and exclusive CBLDF prints by creators such as Frank Miller,

Jeff Smith, Brian K Vaughan, Brad Meltzer, Robert Kirkman, Mike Mignola,

Matt Wagner, Jack Davis, Larry Marder, Terry Moore, Frank Cho and many more

are available at various donation levels.

If your premium donation exceeds $50, you will receive free shipping on your

order until December 15, just in time for the perfect gift for that special

comic fan in everyone's life. Visit www.cbldf.com to see all of what's


CBR News