REVIEW: 'American Splendor': No Phony Crap

Tue, September 2nd, 2003 at 12:00am PDT

TV/Film
Rob Worley, Columnist


Harvey Pekar as Harvey Pekar


Paul Giamatti as Harvey Pekar


Giamatti and Davis

Photo Credit: John Clifford


Joyce Brabner and Harvey Pekar

Photo Credit: John Clifford

Here's a movie for you: A inspiring tale about a real hero who goes on a

great adventure, cheats death, saves a little girl, finds true love and lives

happily ever after.

Well, you won't find any of that "phony Hollywood crap" in

"American Splendor," Shari Springer Berman and Robert Pulcini's filmed

adaptation of Harvey Pekar's comic books.

If you haven't read the comics, "American Splendor" basically

recounts Pekar's cranky, cynical observations about every day life. Tired of

comics that featured superheroes and slick characters he couldn't relate to,

Pekar set out to tell it like it is and show a world that resembled the world he

actually lives in, a world populated by common, work-a-day people, nerds and

misfits who don't have a shred of glamour in their lives. No phony crap.

The movie, like the comics on which it's based, tells Pekar's life story,

starting from when he was you grumpy young boy in Cleveland and leading up to a

real-life 2002 party celebrating his retirement from his day job as a file clerk

at a V.A. hospital. Throughout, we see the ever-grousing Pekar interpreted in as

many different ways as the artists who drew him in the comic.

Paul Giamatti ("Man on the Moon") plays Pekar in the dramatized

scenes, which make up the bulk of the movie. But Pekar himself is there,

narrating and often appearing on camera himself. We see the Pekar of the comics

both as panels drawn by Robert Crumb and others, and as animated characters in

the movie. (We even get Donal Logue ("Grounded for Life") playing the

man in a stage version of the comics).

If all this makes you think Berman and Pulcini are playing with form, you are

correct. "American Splendor" deftly maneuvers between comic panels,

acted scenes and behind-the scenes interviews. Yet rather than coming off as

showy or distracting, all the experimental techniques actually serve the

experience of getting to know Harvey in a way that a conventional film or even a

documentary would not.

Hats off to Giamatti and Hope Davis, who plays Pekar's wife, Joyce Brabner.

Both actors deliver performances that are winning and feel true-to-life. How

difficult is that when the real-life counterparts are right there on the screen

with them?

So, does Harvey do all that stuff I talked about earlier and live happily

ever after? Well, I can't say if he's living happily ever after, but in the

course of the movie he does, in his own grouchy way, cheat death, save a little

girl and find true love.

Does he go on a great adventure? The long, lonely and sometimes frightening

times Pekar spent in the overcast, grimy city of Cleveland may not seem like a

great adventure, but it plays well as a hilarious, compelling and thoroughly

enjoyable film.

Is Harvey a hero? Harvey Pekar is someone who has worked hard, kept his

integrity and made something unique of his life. He's an every day hero and if

someone like Harvey can be a hero, well, maybe the rest of us are the heroes of our own stories. Now isn't that inspiring?

[American Splendor Comic Relief Sweeps!]
Don't forget to enter the "American Splendor Comic Relief

Sweeps." You could win an autographed poster and lots of other cool

prizes!

CBR News

Send This Article to a Friend

Separate multiple email address with commas.

You must state your name.

You must enter your email address.