X-Men Forever #5

by James Hunt, Reviewer |

Send This to a Friend

Separate multiple email address with commas.

You must state your name.

You must enter your email address.

Story by
Chris Claremont
Art by
Tom Grummett, Cory Hamscher
Colors by
Wil Quintana
Letters by
Tom Orzechowski
Cover by
Tom Grummett
Marvel Comics
Cover Price
$3.99 (USD)
Release Date
Aug 12th, 2009

Tue, August 18th, 2009 at 8:09PM (PDT)

When “X-Men Forever” was announced, there was part of me that was intrigued. As someone who started reading the X-books in the early 90s, a continuation of Claremont’s run, starting from that point, had a lot of nostalgic appeal. What we’ve ended up with isn’t really what was promised -- but it’s fair to say, it’s still pretty entertaining.

The central conceit of “X-Men Forever” was quite rapidly ditched, and Claremont has concentrated on spinning new stories instead of continuing old ones. Issue #5 brings the first storyline to a rather abrupt end as the mutant race is given a dramatic new development that, all hyperbole aside, alters the X-Men’s central concept on a fundamental level. It’s a sign that Claremont still has plenty of ideas worth exploring and, it seems, that in “X-Men Forever” Marvel has finally found an appropriate venue for them.

Rarely for a Claremont book, this works rather well on a technical level. While his titles have often felt over-written and dated, here he manages to turn that into an advantage. There’s an appropriately old-school feel to the pacing and exposition, and something pleasantly familiar about the way sub-plots weave in and out of the book after becoming a virtual lost art in today’s long-term, trade-focussed storylines. It took a while to get going, but as of this issue, we can emphatically say that “X-Men Forever” is working, against the odds.

As ever, Tom Grummett’s artwork is a large part of that. He’s no Jim Lee, but he’s a strong storyteller in his own right, and his costumes designs are very appropriate for the era -- Jean’s new Phoenix-inspired look in particular -- and from the cover, it appears the rest of the cast will be getting an overhaul shortly as well.

It probably depends on how much of an X-Men nostalgist you are, but “X-Men Forever” is somehow managing to pull its weight on a level beyond being the Obligatory Chris Claremont Book. If you haven’t checked it out already, it’s certainly worth a look.


X-Men Forever #20
Posted Thu, April 1st

X-Men Forever #19
Posted Wed, March 10th

X-Men Forever #17
Posted Mon, February 15th

X-Men Forever #15
Posted Tue, January 19th

X-Men Forever #13
Posted Fri, December 11th