Supergirl #4

by Greg McElhatton, Reviewer |

Send This to a Friend

Separate multiple email address with commas.

You must state your name.

You must enter your email address.

Story by
Michael Green, Mike Johnson
Art by
Mahmud Asrar
Colors by
Dave McCaig
Letters by
Rob Leigh
Cover by
Mahmud Asrar, Dave McCaig
DC Comics
Cover Price
$2.99 (USD)
Release Date
Dec 21st, 2011

Thu, December 22nd, 2011 at 7:07PM (PST)

We're four issues into the new "Supergirl," and while overall it's not a bad comic, it's hard to shake the feeling that this series is moving at a snail's pace.

By this point in time, we've still got a character who doesn't speak the language of anyone (except for Superman) on Earth, doesn't believe the situation she's in, and has had limited contact with anyone or anything. I get that Michael Green and Mike Johnson are going for a slow burn here, keeping Supergirl as a proverbial fish out of water. Still, there comes a point where the character needs to start getting a little with it before you run the risk of frustrating your readers.

"Supergirl" #4 finishes up the two-part introduction of Mr. Tycho, a character that feels like he's supposed to be Supergirl's version of Lex Luthor. But while Tycho's introduction last issue was interesting, this month transforms him into much more of a standard bad guy. There are still some hints about how Tycho wants to use things learned from Supergirl for his own means but, short of twirling a mustache, he's going a little too off the edge into stereotype.

Supergirl herself, despite her general naiveté, isn't a bad character. Now that the "lash out at everything around her" phase appears to be over, she's coming across as compassionate and a little more centered. I'd like to see this process accelerate a bit, but there's promise in the new Supergirl. She's still operating in so much of a vacuum, though, that it's hard to get a good feel on what she'll be like in the greater DC Comics Universe.

Mahmud Asrar's art is solid. He's best when he gets the big flashy scenes, like Supergirl cold-cocking her captors, or bursting through the floor with a punch and a kick. Tycho's scenes are mostly saved thanks to Asrar, too; that steely gaze of his makes him creepier than the script deals out. There's the occasional panel that feels a little rough here and there, but on the whole I like what Asrar's doing here.

"Supergirl" as a series feels like it's summed up in this issue in terms of quality. It's all right, but it needs a bit more spring to its step. I feel like Green, Johnson, and Asrar have all the pieces in front of them for a really good series, but so far they aren't coming together quite fast enough. Hopefully introductions are almost over and we can start heading forward at full speed soon.


Supergirl #37
Posted Fri, December 19th

Supergirl #26
Posted Fri, December 20th

Supergirl #21
Posted Fri, June 21st

Supergirl #19
Posted Mon, April 22nd

Supergirl #14
Posted Mon, November 26th